CarMax vs Carvana: Honest 2025 Comparison for Buyers & Sellers
Trying to decide between Carvana vs CarMax? You’re not alone. In 2025, both platforms are dominating the used car space with promises of quick sales, flexible financing, and hassle-free delivery. But when it comes down to CarMax vs Carvana, the real question is: which is better for buying or selling a car? Is Carvana’s all-digital approach worth it, or does CarMax’s hybrid model deliver better value?
In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the differences in pricing, customer experience, trade-ins, and delivery so you can confidently choose the right option for your next car move.
First Take: General Overview of Carvana and CarMax
Carvana
Carvana operates entirely online, making it a go-to choice for people who want to avoid dealerships altogether. Its tech-first approach, combined with a user-friendly platform and home delivery service, appeals especially to busy buyers and sellers looking for a smooth, digital experience.
Carvana also streamlines the paperwork process, allowing customers to upload documents, sign contracts digitally, and track every step of their purchase or sale.
CarMax
CarMax blends online convenience with in-person service through its expansive network of retail locations. It’s particularly well-suited for customers who want the flexibility to shop online but still prefer to see and test drive the car in person before making a final decision.
CarMax’s large physical presence also means customers can get immediate answers from staff, have their vehicle inspected on-site, and complete transactions face-to-face, offering a more traditional buying experience with the benefits of modern technology.
CarMax vs Carvana: Ratings on Different Platforms
| Platform | Carvana Rating | CarMax Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot | 4.4 stars | 1.9 stars |
| Google Play | 4.8 stars | 4.2 stars |
| App Store | 4.8 stars | 4.8 stars |
Carvana vs CarMax: The Selling Process
If you’re thinking of selling your car, both Carvana and CarMax offer competitive options, but the experience, speed, and offer amounts can vary. Here’s how each platform handles the car-selling process:
Selling Your Car with Carvana
- 100% Online Process: You can get a quote, upload photos, and finalize the sale entirely online.
- Instant Offer: After entering your VIN and vehicle details, Carvana gives you an instant offer valid for 7 days.
- No In-Person Visit Required: If you accept the offer, they’ll schedule a free pickup from your driveway (in eligible areas).
- Loan Payoff Option: If you still owe money on your vehicle, Carvana will handle the payoff as part of the transaction.
- Fast Payment: You’ll receive payment via direct deposit or check immediately upon pickup or delivery of the vehicle.
Selling Your Car with CarMax
- Get an Online or In-Store Offer: Begin online by entering your vehicle info, then choose between bringing the car in or continuing online.
- In-Person Appraisal Advantage: Offers made online are subject to revision upon inspection at a CarMax location.
- 7-Day Offer Guarantee: Once you receive an offer, it’s locked in for 7 days regardless of market fluctuations.
- Instant Payment: Once the deal is finalized, CarMax cuts you a check the same day, no waiting.
- No Obligation: You can walk away with no pressure even after the appraisal.
When considering selling your car, it’s always good to explore all your options. Check out the best places to sell your car for more platforms and tips.
Selling Price Comparison
| Platform | Instant Online Offer | Average Payout (2025) |
|---|---|---|
| Carvana | Yes | $17,500 |
| CarMax | Yes | $18,200 |
Carvana vs CarMax: The Buying Process
Carvana and CarMax both offer modern, no-hassle car buying, but they cater to different preferences. Here’s how the buying process compares:
Buying from Carvana
- Fully online: From browsing to checkout, the entire process is digital. If you’re exploring other fully online options, the detailed list of sites to buy a car online might be useful.
- 360° vehicle views: Interactive images highlight imperfections and features.
- Home delivery: Touchless delivery is available in many areas.
- No haggling: Transparent, fixed pricing.
- 7-day return: Try the car and return it within a week if it’s not a fit.
Buying from CarMax
- Hybrid experience: Shop online or at one of 220+ locations.
- 24-hour test drives: Try before you buy in select areas.
- Pickup or delivery: Choose what’s most convenient.
- Fixed pricing: No negotiations needed.
- 30-day return: Return within 30 days or 1,500 miles.
Buying Experience Comparison
| Platform | Fully Online Purchase | Return Policy | Average Vehicle Price (2025) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carvana | Yes | 7 Days | $19,000 – $24,000 |
| CarMax | Yes (with in-store option) | 30 Days / 1,500 miles | $18,000 – $23,000 |
Key Insight:
- Carvana’s prices tend to run slightly higher due to its nationwide delivery service and online-first infrastructure.
- CarMax may offer slightly better deals on similar models, especially if you’re willing to visit a store.
Carvana vs CarMax: Features Comparison Table
| Feature | Carvana | CarMax |
|---|---|---|
| Shopping Experience | 100% online | Online + in-store |
| Test Drive | Not available | 24-hour test drive (select areas) |
| Home Delivery | Available in many areas | Available in select areas |
| Pickup Option | At a vending machine (select cities) | At the local store |
| Vehicle Inspection | 150-point check | 125+ point check |
| Warranty | 100-day / 4,189-mile limited warranty | 90-day / 4,000-mile limited warranty |
| Trade-In Process | Online quote + free pickup | Online or in-store appraisal |
| Financing Options | In-house + third-party | In-house + third-party |
| Customer Support | Online chat, phone | Online chat, phone, in-person |
| Return policy | 7-day money-back guarantee (400-mile limit) | 10-day money-back guarantee (condition consistent) |
Final Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Choose Carvana if you want a 100% online car buying or selling experience, especially if you live far from physical locations and appreciate app-based convenience.
Choose CarMax if you want to test drive before buying, appreciate the comfort of physical locations, or want more time to return a vehicle.
What Do We Suggest?
We suggest Carvana for most buyers and sellers in 2025 due to its seamless, fully digital process, wide delivery coverage, and user-friendly app. If convenience and speed are your top priorities, Carvana offers a modern, hassle-free experience without needing to visit a dealership.
Conclusion
Choosing between Carvana and CarMax ultimately depends on your priorities. If you value a fully digital, convenient, and quick experience, Carvana stands out with its seamless online process and home delivery. On the other hand, if you prefer the option to test drive, visit a store, or want a longer return window, CarMax’s hybrid model offers flexibility and reassurance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does CarMax or Carvana pay more when selling my car?
Is CarMax or Carvana better?
Can I test-drive cars bought from Carvana?
How long is CarMax’s return policy?
Do both Carvana and CarMax offer financing?
Is home delivery available from both Carvana and CarMax?
Are there any fees for selling or buying cars on these platforms?
a4AutoTransport is a group of auto transport researchers and experts that comes in handy for anyone who wants to move their car/vehicle without putting extra miles on the odometer. At a4AutoTransport, We researched over a hundred car shipping companies, interviewed real customers and industry leaders, and collected nearly 500 quotes to find the nation’s best auto transport companies. With our combined 5 years of industry experience and research, we’ll help you find the right car shipper for your budget.
