Carvana vs Truecar: Honest 2025 Comparison You Shouldn’t Miss
Choosing between Carvana vs TrueCar can feel overwhelming, especially with so many online car-buying platforms competing for attention in 2025. Both promise convenience, transparency, and savings, but they often live up to those claims in very different ways. In this honest 2025 comparison of Carvana vs TrueCar, we’ll walk you through ratings of each platform, how each platform works, and what to watch out for so you can decide which is best for your next car purchase.
Carvana vs TrueCar: What Is the Big Difference?
The key difference lies in how each platform operates. Carvana acts as a direct dealer, meaning you buy the car straight from them with no middleman involved. On the other hand, TrueCar functions as a marketplace and pricing tool, connecting you with local dealerships where the actual purchase takes place.
In short, Carvana sells you the car directly, while TrueCar helps you find dealers and compare prices.
Now, Take a Proper Overview of Both Sites
What is TrueCar?
TrueCar stands out as one of the best used car websites by providing an online car-buying platform that connects buyers with a network of certified dealerships. It offers transparent pricing data for both new and used cars, helping buyers compare offers and find competitive deals locally or nationwide. TrueCar also features a trade-in program called True Cash Offer to simplify selling your current vehicle, adding another layer of convenience for users.
What is Carvana?
Carvana is a fully online used car retailer that allows customers to browse, finance, purchase, and sell vehicles without visiting a dealership. Known for its home delivery and car vending machines, Carvana offers a seamless buying experience, including a 7-day return policy and free vehicle pick-up for sellers.
So, That Means Carvana Provides Car Shipping Service, but TrueCar Doesn’t?
Yes, that’s correct. Carvana offers nationwide car delivery and pickup options, making the entire process online-friendly from purchase to doorstep delivery. TrueCar, however, does not provide shipping services directly; instead, it connects you with local dealerships, and any delivery or pickup arrangements depend on the dealer you choose.
Ratings on Trusted Platforms
Compare how Carvana and TrueCar are rated across trusted platforms
| Platform | TrueCar Rating | Carvana Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot | 2.2 stars | 4.4 stars |
| Consumer Affairs | 1.0 stars | 3.5 stars |
| Google Play | 3.9 stars | 4.8 stars |
| App Store | 4.7 stars | 4.8 stars |
How Does Carvana Work?
- Browse cars online through Carvana’s website or app
- Select your car and review detailed photos, specs, and history report
- Arrange financing, payment, or trade-in completely online
- Choose home delivery or pickup from a Carvana vending machine
- Get a 7-day return policy to test and return if it’s not the right fit
Is Buying a Car on Carvana Cheaper or Expensive Than a Dealership?
Is Buying a Car on Carvana Cheaper or Expensive Than a Dealership?
Carvana isn’t always cheaper than a dealership. Its prices are generally set at fair market value, so while you avoid haggling and extra dealership fees, you’re mainly paying for convenience and transparency rather than deep discounts.
What Makes Carvana Better Than Using an In-Person Dealership?
Carvana stands out for its hassle-free, no-pressure buying process. With transparent pricing, simple online financing, and delivery to your door, it saves time and eliminates the stress of negotiating in a traditional dealership setting.
How Does TrueCar Work?
- Search for new or used cars on TrueCar’s website or app
- View the Price Report to see what others in your area paid
- Compare dealer listings and available incentives
- Connect with TrueCar Certified Dealers for the final purchase
- Use the True Cash Offer tool to sell or trade in your car
What Exactly Is TrueCar’s Price Report and How Do You Use It?
The Price Report shows real transaction data so you can compare what others actually paid for similar vehicles. This helps you judge whether a listing is a fair deal before visiting a dealer.
Can You Complete the Entire Car Purchase Online with TrueCar?
Not fully! TrueCar mainly connects you to certified dealers. While you can browse, compare, and get quotes online, the actual purchase usually takes place at the dealership, unless TrueCar+ is available in your state.
TrueCar vs Carvana: Some Other Key Differences
Return & Warranty Policies Comparison
| Platform | Return Policy | Warranty |
|---|---|---|
| TrueCar | 7 days | 100-day limited |
| Carvana | Varies by dealer | Dealer dependant |
Financing Options
- Carvana: Offers its own in-house financing with instant online pre-qualification and soft credit checks, simplifying the loan process.
- TrueCar: Financing is provided through partnered dealerships, and terms, interest rates, and approval speed can vary widely.
Customer Support & Return Policies
- Carvana:
- Provides a 7-day return policy with no questions asked.
- Includes a 100-day limited warranty on most purchases.
- Multiple support channels including live chat, phone, email, and social media.
- TrueCar:
- No universal return policy—terms depend on the individual dealership.
- Support is primarily managed by the dealer; TrueCar provides minimal post-sale assistance.
User Experience & Website Tools
- Carvana: Features a sleek, user-friendly interface with 360° car views, real-time financing, and transparent delivery scheduling.
- TrueCar: Offers powerful pricing insights, side-by-side comparisons, and access to new car market data to guide buying decisions.
Cars Accepted
- Carvana: Accepts most vehicles from model year 1992 and newer, provided they are in running condition. Also accepts some salvage and rebuilt title vehicles.
- TrueCar: Will make offers on vehicles in various conditions—including damaged, junk, or non-running cars, depending on the dealer network.
Vehicle Turnaround Time
- Carvana: Offers fast vehicle delivery or pickup within 24–48 hours after purchase. Selling turnaround is typically within 1–2 days after accepting an offer.
- TrueCar: Turnaround times depend on dealership availability and scheduling. Selling a car may require 2–3 days including dealer inspection.
Carvana vs TrueCar: Pros and Cons Comparison
TrueCar
Pros
- 100% online car buying and selling experience
- Home delivery and vending machine pickup options
- 7-day return policy with no questions asked
- In-house financing with soft credit checks
- Accepts some salvage and rebuilt title vehicles
Cons
- Prices are often slightly higher due to convenience
- Limited to used cars only (no new car inventory)
- No option for price negotiation
Carvana
Pros
- Access to both new and used car listings
- Aggregates offers from multiple dealerships
- Helpful pricing data and market insights
- May get multiple trade-in offers from dealers
- Well-rated app for research and comparisons
Cons
- The final purchase must be completed at a dealership
- Return and warranty policies vary by dealer
- Limited post-sale customer support
Summary Comparison Table
| Feature | Carvana | TrueCar |
|---|---|---|
| Platform Type | Fully online used car retailer | Price comparison and dealer aggregator |
| Inventory | 45,000+ used cars | New & used cars from certified dealers |
| Buy Online? | Yes | No (purchase at dealership) |
| Vehicle Delivery | Home delivery or vending machines | Dealer-arranged pickup |
| Return Policy | 7 days | Varies by dealer |
| Warranty | 100-day limited | Varies by dealer |
| Financing | In-house financing available | Dealer-dependent financing |
| Vehicle Types Accepted | Running vehicles (1992+), some salvage/rebuilt | Damaged or junk cars accepted (dealer-dependent) |
| Mobile App Quality | 4.8 stars, end-to-end process | 4.7 stars, focused on research |
Alternatives to Carvana and TrueCar
CarMax
No-haggle pricing, nationwide inventory, online + in-store options
Large selection & trusted buying process
Vroom
Online-only car sales with delivery and a 7-day return policy
Similar to Carvana, with full online convenience
AutoTrader
Marketplace with dealer + private listings
Huge variety and flexibility in pricing
Final Decision: Which Should You Choose?
If convenience, full control, and a 100% online experience are your top priorities, Carvana is the clear winner. From financing to delivery, everything is streamlined for a hassle-free car buying or selling process.
However, if you’re looking for more price flexibility, want to buy a new car, or prefer to compare multiple local offers, TrueCar provides valuable dealership insights and negotiation leverage.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, Carvana is best for those seeking a fast, fully online car buying or selling experience, while TrueCar is ideal for shoppers who want price comparisons and access to new car deals through local dealerships. Your decision should depend on whether you prefer digital convenience or in-person flexibility, both platforms offer valuable tools to simplify your vehicle transaction in 2025.
FAQs
Is it cheaper to buy a car on Carvana or TrueCar?
Does Carvana accept damaged or wrecked vehicles?
Does TrueCar buy damaged vehicles?
Can I return a car to Carvana or TrueCar?
Who has better financing—Carvana or TrueCar?
Can I buy a new car through Carvana?
Which platform is better for first-time car buyers?
Is there a TrueCar comparison with other car-buying sites?
What do users say about TrueCar Reddit discussions?
What do users say about Carvana Reddit threads?
a4AutoTransport is a group of auto transport researchers and experts that comes in handy for anyone who wants to move their car/vehicle without putting extra miles on the odometer. At a4AutoTransport, We researched over a hundred car shipping companies, interviewed real customers and industry leaders, and collected nearly 500 quotes to find the nation’s best auto transport companies. With our combined 5 years of industry experience and research, we’ll help you find the right car shipper for your budget.
